Oh brother where art thou vs the odyssey. How is 'O' Brother Where Art Thou?', based on Homer's the Odyssey? 2019-02-04

Oh brother where art thou vs the odyssey Rating: 7,8/10 428 reviews

FREE Comparison of The Odyssey and O Brother Where Art Thou Essay

oh brother where art thou vs the odyssey

The poem and movie have the same main stories, but some of the details are changed. Another comparison between the two stories is in storytelling by the prophets. Even in the 21st century The Odyssey is still depicting its prominence when the film O Brother, Where Art Thou was directed in 2000 by loosely portraying the epic. Everett has promised Pete and Delmar that if they help him escape the chain gang in which they are confined to, he will in return provide them with treasures. Both characters are presented as eloquent speakers, able to influence others with their ability to communicate. Are the two versions the same? Due to the fact that O Brother, Where Art Thou? They walk down to the river and start getting baptized. He told the three men that they will not find the treasure they seek.

Next

O Brother Where Art Thou and Odyssey Comparison

oh brother where art thou vs the odyssey

Near the beginning of O Brother, Where Art Thou? The similarities between O Brother, Where Art Thou? In O Brother Where Art Thou? When one looks as Odysseus and Ulysses, there seems to be nothing in common between the two. The story is so foggy and distracted by the unneeded details, and it abandons the true meaning of the heartwarming story. What does it mean to take a piece of literature and put it onto film? Another unique part about this film is that the main character is currently divorced and wanting to remarry… 936 Words 4 Pages man to take over. In fact, Everett takes special notice that they are his daughters and should carry his name. Time has not become the conqueror for the classical epic poem The Odyssey. The first and most obvious similarity between the movie and the text are the main character's names.

Next

The Odyssey vs. O Brother, Where Art Thou? by Oviya Sugum on Prezi

oh brother where art thou vs the odyssey

While Everett is not physically damaged, the Sirens do play a role in slowing his progress toward his ultimate goal. Therefore, it is appropriate to consider the elements that are inherent in film and novel, and how those can, or cannot, be transferred from one to the other. In O Brother, Where Art Thou? Of course, he maintains his skepticism, but he doubts his doubts a bit more than before. Big Dan, a mighty brute with an eye patch gives off the same rueful, vain behavior as Polyphemus does when he captures his crew. O Brother, Where Art Thou? In the book, Odysseus and his crew come upon the land of the Lotus-Eaters. Penelope is such a heartwarming, in depth part of the poem where odysseus meets his wife once again.


Next

O Brother, Where Art Thou

oh brother where art thou vs the odyssey

The Coen brothers, writers and directors of the film, did not over analyze their representation. The political components of the written story are limited to Odysseus returning home to assume his role as king, taking his place with his queen. He sets out to seek his father, he opposes the enemy at home, and he holds things together until the father returns, when they both ultimately overcome the suitors. Is it appropriate for the filmmaker to make changes, or must he or she tell the story exactly as written? Both characters share many similarities. In The Odyssey, Odysseus goes down into the Underworld where Agamemnon warns him about the dangers of women. Since the film presents the story through sight and sound, it is only natural that such a medium will differ from the written work. There are many other minor characters that are presented in both versions, but one important similarity is the way both stories bring in popular cultural figures of the day.

Next

The Odyssey and O Brother, Where Art Thou?

oh brother where art thou vs the odyssey

However, there are some stories that simply do not capture the essence of breathtaking adventure. Ulysses meets a one eyed man who gets poked in the eye, but by a fallen cross. They can also be compared to Circe, due to the fact that Delmar thought Pete was turned into a toad. From there Everet, Pete, and Delmar take trying to escape the tracking dogs. Penny went on to describe about how she had not missed him one bit.

Next

O Brother Where Art Thou and Odyssey Comparison

oh brother where art thou vs the odyssey

Introduction The Odyssey , is an epic poem by Homer written based off of a true hero's journey back home. Only the intervention of a flood saves Everett and his companions. Likewise, the enemies that are encountered by Odysseus and Everett articulate a fidelity to the essence of the story, while clearly demonstrating that that essence can be presented in multiple ways. All of which are typical of being a main character. Both allow for supernatural elements to oppose, or at times to support, the hero on his journey. The Cyclops is one of the most important trials Odysseus and his crew face. Both women are strong willed and know what they want.

Next

The Oddessy Vs. O Brother Where Art Thou Essay

oh brother where art thou vs the odyssey

I already turned it in, but thanks everyone for the feedback. The other is a smelly man seeking refuge after escaping from prison. A traveling salesman would be much more appropriate. The third similarity is the next way the crews get blown off course. Ulysses Everett McGill portrays Odysseus, the hero of The Odyssey. I'd say mine was in the upper third, possibly better. In fact, Stam and Hutcheon both argue that this is impossible to accomplish Hutcheon 7.

Next

The Odyssey vs. O Brother, where art thou? • The Village

oh brother where art thou vs the odyssey

Another similarity is that, in both the Odyssey and O Brother, Where Art Thou, the Sirens are present. Ten years after the war, Odysseus retraces his steps back home. In the Odyssey, Penelope was the one thing that fueled Odysseus's journey home, t. Even in the most deep, beautiful scenes such as Penelope, there was a distinct failure by the creators of the film. It makes the movie so much more meaningful when you have read the book and can make the connections. Also, Pete and Delmar, Everett's loyal crew appear to be as dumb as the crew written The Odyssey. The Coen brothers have created such a disappointing excuse for capturing a real hero and his adventures to be reunited with his true love.

Next

How is 'O' Brother Where Art Thou?', based on Homer's the Odyssey?

oh brother where art thou vs the odyssey

In order for man to remain in his head position, he will face and go through a variety of obstacles. It becomes clear when he tries to torment them as much as possible while making their journey awful. Using examples from both stories, the method of storytelling, and the benefits and advantages of each can be made evident. Movies cannot do this, as they must have continuous action Chatman 407-8. Although the look completely different, there is quite a bit in common.

Next